The ‘When’ and ‘What’ of a project Social Investment Strategy

Before you go ahead, think ahead: Does the impacted community approve of the project? What are the community’s expectations? Can you meet those expectations? If not, then what? What is the capability of the industry regulator? What are the expected environmental and social impacts? What is the narrative about the project in the national discourse? What would be the impact of a change in government?

The answers to some of these questions can disrupt your elegant financial models. Larry Fink, the chief executive at BlackRock, the world’s biggest asset manager with US$4.6 trillion under management, knows this—environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues are core business issues. In a February 2016 letter to CEOs, he writes that ESG issues have real and quantifiable financial impacts.

Newmont, the world’s second biggest gold miner, knows this too. Despite a ruling by Peru’s Constitutional Court paving the way for the development of the Conga mine in that country, the miner had to walk away from the US$5 billion copper and gold project, unable to withstand violent opposition by the community.

So the need for a clear ESG strategy and the competent management of such is, thankfully, accepted wisdom among serious investors—we hope.

But how to do it?  In this piece, we focus on the ‘S’ of ESG and specifically on social investment plans and programmes.

If you begin thinking about stakeholder engagement, social impact management, and social investment issues after approval, you have waited too long. As investors race to help plug Africa’s US$90 billion annual infrastructure gap, and as companies lay the groundwork for a rebound in oil, gas, and mining, we at Kina Advisory see many companies struggle with the issue of the timing of such activities—when to do what. For instance, when to start consulting the community (without creating unrealistic expectations), when to announce a social investment program (before or after an election), and when to start implementing a social investment programme (before or after approval of a plan of development or power purchase agreement).

Tough questions, admittedly, with no easy answers. It’s a context-specific art, but one that must be grounded in information, best practices, and the connections, experience, and skills of specialists. To help investors, Kina Advisory has outlined suggested activities for the five main phases of a project.

Phase 1—Early development. During project identification and feasibility studies, an investor would need enough information to make a go/no-go decision. Here, activities would focus on investigating the ecosystem of the project: physical environment, political environment, economic environment, legal requirements, communities to be impacted, availability of skilled labor, and other critical issues. The information gathered can be used to begin to formulate a vision for social and economic contribution. Many governments now require that vision and related activities are part of project proposals – so social investment plans are becoming a compliance requirement. Even where they are not, any developer is well-served to articulate such in order to get a leg up. Besides, such a company gets a better grasp on managing risks. Conducting community consultations at this stage must be done tactfully so as not to raise expectations. Also, competitors may be conducting similar surveys, thereby overwhelming the community. An experienced advisor can estimate the nature and cost of managing such activities to help the investor make that go/no-go decision.

Phase 2—Advanced Development. Now is the time to begin executing some level of social investment or community investment programmes. It begins with more comprehensive consultation with stakeholders and a deeper understanding of the country’s economic development strategy.  Even where a company is using an external partner to assist in designing and implementing such programmes, developing in-house capacity would be critical. That would involve cultivating an internal mind-set that values partnership and underpins a more considered approach to stakeholder engagement.

Phase 3—Execution/ Construction. The construction stage is the first test of the robustness of the ESG strategy and management systems. It is the time to begin implementing some of the social investments to smooth the way for construction and related activities. Besides, as the project becomes tangible, its visibility increases and issues will come up that must be managed.

Phase 4—Operation. The operational phase should be one with a constant feedback loop, involving execution of the social investment programme, continuously listening for feedback, monitoring and evaluating programs, and correcting course when needed. In Ghana, for instance, years after a company started operating a plantation acquired from the State, local chiefs started making demands on the basis that customary practices had not been followed in the procurement of the land. But of course the only way to sustain any social investment is by maintaining operational excellence of the core business—while managing all the external forces.

Phase 5—Decommissioning. Often overlooked, the decommissioning process is important not only for the extractive industries. For many other industries, there are compliance issues to deal with. Programs may come to a halt, buildings may be abandoned, jobs would be lost, so it is never a frictionless process. Again, this phase begins with consultation with key stakeholders, especially the impacted community, including helping to identify alternative livelihoods. In many cases, partnerships must be forged to carry on with programs.

The array of actors and factors at play throughout the project lifecycle illustrate the need for a robust stakeholder engagement and communications strategy to underpin any social investment – and for that strategy to be adaptable to each stage. It is also critical for that strategy to include explaining to stakeholders the company’s core business and how it ties in with its social investment. This stops the social investment strategy from being seen simply as a ‘social wash’ PR plan.

While every situation is different these guidelines may be useful in helping companies understand their ESG needs at any phase in a project, and thereby avoid the misallocation of resources or opening themselves up to even more risk.

Trina Fahey, Partner

To know more about our services, please click here

To comment on the article, please click here

What we are up to & News

28|05|2020

Joël Rault joins Kina’s Advisory Board

We are thrilled to have Joël Rault, Chairman and Founder of Hermès Advisory, join our Advisory Board. Joël has previously served as an Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary for the Government of France and has extensive experience in administration and the management of private companies. He is also an emerging leader of the Harvard Kennedy School. We are looking forward to having his advice and guidance as we forge ahead with advising companies operating in Africa on Sustainability. For our full press release, ‘click here’

02|05|2020

Invest Africa Ltd’s Webinar On Renewable Energy Solutions in Africa

Join our Managing Director, Rosalind Kainyah MBE, as she moderates Invest Africa’s webinar on Renewable Energy Solutions in Africa – Covid19, Sustainability & the future of the continent with Jennifer Boca of Lekela Power, Mansoor Hamayun of BBOXX and Scott Mackin of Denham Capital. They will be looking at whether investment bodies will have to pivot away from renewable energy assets in light of COVID-19; how renewable energy operations have been affected by the virus; the multilateral funds such as AfDB’s SEFA play in renewable energy developments across Africa; and the importance funds should place on ESG standards in the investment decision?

Date: Wednesday 6 May 2020.  Time: 12:00-13:00 BST

For more information, please click here:

 

Rosalind Kainyah moderates Invest Africa’s webinar on Renewable Energy Solutions in Africa

27|11|2019

Kina Advisory is proud to be an event partner of DLA Piper – Africa Week 2019

On the 28th November, Kina Advisory is proud to be an event partner of DLA Piper – Africa Week 2019. The theme for the day is“Africa: the future of trade and investment” and will be facilitated by Lanre A. editor of Nurmara and former editor of This Is Africa at the Financial Times and African Business. Our MD Rosalind Kainyah MBE will be moderating a session in the afternoon on: “Developing sustainable energy and natural resource projects: Implementing ESG in practice” | The panel will be made up of Jack Cunningham – Sustainability, Policy & Risk Director, Gemfields, Rhys Davies – Partner, DLA Piper, Chris Goodwin-Hudson – Founder, Watchman & Carla McRoberts – Managing Director, Veracity Worldwide | For a full breakdown of the day click here: 

21|10|2019

Rosalind Kainyah MBE will be chairing the 5th Africa Oil Governance Summit

Rosalind Kainyah MBE will be chairing the 5th Africa Oil Governance Summit on the 22nd & 23rd October 2019 & facilitating the 1st panel on “Value addition to petroleum resources extraction through industrialization: The possibilities and the challenges”.  For a full break down of speaker & agenda, click here.

23|09|2019

Africa | Attracting a New Wave of Investors

Rosalind Kainyah our Managing Director will be moderating a panel discussion for Invest Africa & DLA Piper on Wednesday 25th Sept 2019.  The Topic: Attracting a New Wave of Investors: Corporate Governance and Meeting International Standards | For the full details of who’s on the panel and focus points, click here.